clock menu more-arrow no yes

Filed under:

Midseason Top 100 Fantasy Prospect List

New, 49 comments

With the All Star Break upon us, let's take a look at our updated top 100 fantasy prospect lists.

Rob Carr/Getty Images

We have reached the point in the season where updated prospect lists are coming out and we are no exception. Here at Fake Teams, we strive to provide excellent fantasy baseball coverage, including the minor leagues. With that in mind, below you will find the midseason top 100 fantasy prospect lists from our prospect writers, Jason Hunt and Alex Bell

There are three key things to remember when looking at our prospect lists. First, these rankings represent the long-term view, and as such does not include only the production expected this year, but also the overall long-term projection. With this, you're going to see a player like Lucas Giolito who is unlikely to have any impact at all in 2015 and potentially even 2016 ranked highly, as he can potentially be a top 10 starting pitcher in the majors once he does arrive. Second, prospect rankings are always a snapshot in time, as they represent how we view the player at the moment the list is published, based on the information available at that time. While we try to make our best estimate of what we expect in terms of a player's development, each new report or bit of information found over time continues to update the prospect's story. Player development is not linear, and so there are undoubtedly going rankings that are going to look amazing in the future, and others that will look absolutely terrible. Finally, each ranker will value different things higher (or lower) than other rankers. Some tend to value prospects with higher floors even if they have lower potential upsides, and I know that I can have specific biases towards certain profiles as well. These things don't necessarily make us right or wrong, just different.

The State of the Minors

2015 has arguably provided one of the best crop of graduating prospects in recent memory, both in terms of elite prospects and in overall quantity of prospects. We've seen top prospects like Kris Bryant, Carlos Correa, and Joc Pederson all providing meaningful contributions for both their teams and our fantasy ones, to the point where prospects like Noah Syndergaard, Lance McCullers, and Chris Heston may be on the outside looking in for Rookie of the Year votes despite strong showings of their own. These things are cyclical in nature, but the number of potentially elite options coming up and producing like this in the same season is rare.

With that in mind, the overall talent level in the minor leagues appears to be less top heavy than at the start of the season. By no means does that mean that the minors are down, but rather that we are waiting to see the next group of potential elite talents to emerge from the lower minors and this year's draft. There are many interesting prospects in the lower minors right now that could take the the next step forward, and jump up even further in the offseason prospect rankings.

The Details and the Process

Our rankings are based on a standard 5x5 scoring format, and rather than providing a consensus list of our rankers, we provide the individual rankings for each person. This is done in part because with just two rankers, the consensus can look rather unusual on some prospects.

Our process is for each of our rankers to produce their own individual lists, which are then send to the other rankers for review and discussion. The goal of this review is not necessarily to make statements about a player's ranking being right or wrong, but rather to get an understanding of how a ranking was reached, and whether a change may be warranted with additional information or discussion. At the end of this, are the lists you find below.

Some specifics to be aware of:

1. We are including any prospects who are in the majors but have not surpassed their rookie eligibility. That means players like Byron Buxton and Steven Matz remain on the list, while Carlos Correa and Noah Syndergaard are not any longer.

2. We have removed both Hector Olivera and Rusney Castillo from our lists, as both are not prospects in the standard mold given their professional experience from Cuba. Both would fall in the top 20 for me were they eligible.

3. We have included 2015 draftees who have signed as of Sunday as eligible players, so that means that top pick Dansby Swanson wasn't eligible, but Alex Bregman and Brendan Rodgers were.

We will be around throughout the next couple days to answer questions as well, so if you have a specific player you're interested in hearing about, let us know. And to get this out of the way, yes, it's very possible that we don't like your favorite team's prospects (Ok, maybe not).

Jason Alex
Player Pos Team Rank Player Pos Team
Byron Buxton OF MIN 1 Julio Urias LHP LAD
Corey Seager SS LAD 2 Corey Seager SS LAD
Lucas Giolito RHP WAS 3 Byron Buxton OF MIN
Kyle Schwarber C/OF CHC 4 Jose Berrios RHP MIN
Miguel Sano 3B MIN 5 Jose Peraza SS ATL
Julio Urias LHP LAD 6 Luis Severino RHP NYY
Joey Gallo 3B TEX 7 Tyler Glasnow RHP PIT
Nomar Mazara OF TEX 8 Manuel Margot OF BOS
Steven Matz LHP NYM 9 J.P. Crawford SS PHI
J.P. Crawford SS PHI 10 Joey Gallo 3B TEX
Yoan Moncada 2B BOS 11 Lucas Giolito RHP WAS
Francisco Lindor SS CLE 12 Alen Hanson 2B PIT
Tim Anderson SS CHW 13 Aaron Nola RHP PHI
Brendan Rodgers SS COL 14 Steven Matz LHP NYM
Aaron Judge OF NYY 15 Jameson Taillon RHP PIT
David Dahl OF COL 16 Andrew Benintendi OF BOS
Jeff Hoffman RHP TOR 17 Yoan Moncada 2B BOS
Rafael Devers 3B BOS 18 Dillon Tate RHP TEX
Aaron Nola RHP PHI 19 Nomar Mazara OF TEX
Tyler Glasnow RHP PIT 20 Alex Reyes RHP STL
Trea Turner SS WAS 21 Francisco Lindor SS CLE
Nick Williams OF TEX 22 Ozhaino Albies SS ATL
Jose Berrios RHP MIN 23 David Dahl OF COL
Alex Reyes RHP STL 24 Ian Happ OF CHC
Daniel Norris LHP TOR 25 Franklin Barreto SS OAK
Manuel Margot OF BOS 26 Orlando Arcia SS MIL
Bradley Zimmer OF CLE 27 Bradley Zimmer OF CLE
Robert Stephenson RHP CIN 28 Rafael Devers 3B BOS
Archie Bradley RHP ARI 29 Jesse Winker OF CIN
Jose De Leon RHP LAD 30 Daniel Norris LHP TOR
Dansby Swanson SS ARI 31 Matt Wisler RHP ATL
Dalton Pompey OF TOR 32 Brett Phillips OF HOU
Raimel Tapia OF COL 33 Miguel Sano 3B MIN
Brett Phillips OF HOU 34 Dylan Bundy RHP BAL
Matt Wisler RHP ATL 35 Alex Bregman SS HOU
Chi Chi Gonzalez RHP TEX 36 Raul Mondesi SS KCR
Jose Peraza SS ATL 37 Raimel Tapia OF COL
Jake Thompson RHP TEX 38 Kyle Schwarber C/OF CHC
Michael Conforto OF NYM 39 Ariel Jurado RHP TEX
Grant Holmes RHP LAD 40 Michael Kopech LHP BOS
Austin Meadows OF PIT 41 Nick Gordon SS MIN
Sean Newcomb LHP LAA 42 Stephen Gonsalves LHP MIN
Ryan McMahon 3B COL 43 Brady Aiken LHP CLE
Clint Frazier OF CLE 44 Antonio Senzatela RHP COL
Alex Bregman SS HOU 45 Rio Ruiz 3B ATL
Josh Bell 1B PIT 46 Garrett Whitley OF TAM
Rymer Liriano OF SD 47 Jacob Faria RHP TAM
Andrew Benintendi OF BOS 48 Brendan Rodgers SS COL
Stephen Piscotty OF STL 49 Dalton Pompey OF TOR
Gleyber Torres SS CHC 50 Aaron Blair RHP ARI
Ozhaino Albies SS ATL 51 Nate Smith LHP LAA
Dan Vogelbach 1B CHC 52 Gleyber Torres SS CHC
Jon Gray RHP COL 53 Trenton Clark OF MIL
Willy Adames SS TAM 54 Daz Cameron OF HOU
Jorge Alfaro C TEX 55 Kyle Tucker OF HOU
Hunter Renfroe OF SD 56 Roman Quinn OF PHI
Luis Severino RHP NYY 57 Dustin Fowler OF NYY
Brady Aiken LHP CLE 58 Nick Plummer OF STL
Billy McKinney OF CHC 59 Chance Sisco C BAL
Jesse Winker OF CIN 60 Brett Honeywell RHP TAM
Mark Appel RHP HOU 61 Rob Kaminsky LHP STL
Jameson Taillon RHP PIT 62 Trea Turner SS WAS
Dylan Bundy RHP BAL 63 Mallex Smith OF ATL
Hunter Harvey RHP BAL 64 Robert Stephenson RHP CIN
Ian Happ OF CHC 65 Max Kepler OF MIN
Franklin Barreto SS OAK 66 Omar Carrizales OF COL
Daniel Robertson SS TAM 67 Zach Davies RHP BAL
Wilmer Difo 2B WAS 68 Nick Williams OF TEX
Sean Manaea LHP KCR 69 Cole Tucker SS PIT
Derek Fisher OF HOU 70 Ashe Russell RHP KCR
Kyle Tucker OF HOU 71 Willy Adames SS TAM
Marco Gonzales LHP STL 72 Darnell Sweeney 2B LAD
Joe Ross RHP WAS 73 Duane Underwood RHP CHC
Alex Jackson OF SEA 74 Jorge Polanco SS MIN
Brett Honeywell RHP TAM 75 Tyler Jay LHP MIN
Blake Snell LHP TAM 76 Mauricio Dubon SS BOS
Duane Underwood RHP CHC 77 Sam Travis 1B BOS
Dillon Tate RHP TEX 78 Stephen Piscotty OF STL
Tyler Beede RHP SF 79 Brady Lail RHP NYY
Vince Velasquez RHP HOU 80 Zach Eflin RHP PHI
Henry Owens LHP BOS 81 Jake Thompson RHP TEX
Orlando Arcia SS MIL 82 Corey Black RHP CHC
Jorge Mateo SS NYY 83 Henry Owens LHP BOS
Raul Mondesi SS KCR 84 Trevor Story SS COL
Reynaldo Lopez RHP WAS 85 Michael Conforto OF NYM
Luis Ortiz RHP TEX 86 Casey Meisner LHP NYM
Nick Plummer OF STL 87 Hunter Harvey RHP BAL
Alen Hanson 2B PIT 88 Grant Holmes RHP LAD
Sean Reid-Foley RHP TOR 89 Jose Rondon SS SD
Brandon Nimmo OF NYM 90 Auston Bousfield OF SD
Nick Gordon SS MIN 91 Cornelius Randolph OF PHI
Roman Quinn OF PHI 92 Jacob Nottingham C HOU
Francelis Montas RHP CHW 93 Carlos Tocci OF PHI
Tyler Kolek RHP MIA 94 Raisel Iglesias RHP CIN
Alex Verdugo OF LAD 95 Tim Anderson SS CHW
Forrest Wall 2B COL 96 Devin Williams RHP MIL
Phil Ervin OF CIN 97 Tyler Mahle RHP CIN
Garrett Whitley OF TAM 98 Greg Harris RHP TAM
Amir Garrett LHP CIN 99 Jorge Mateo SS NYY
Michael Kopech LHP BOS 100 Jeff Hoffman RHP TOR