clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

2 to Watch: Midseason Review

Normally, I profile two interesting players, but this time I'm reviewing all of the players I've looked at so far in 2015. How good has my advice been?

Adam Lind has been one of my favorite "buys" of the season. Who else did I get right?
Adam Lind has been one of my favorite "buys" of the season. Who else did I get right?
Bill Streicher-USA TODAY Sports

Welcome to week 15 of 2 to Watch! To read previous editions of 2 to Watch, check out this link. I'm going to break from the usual format to review how all of the players I've featured so far this season have done before and after my profiles. I want to be transparent and show you all how good passable I am at identifying players whose stock is going up and those that are on the way down. Consider this my first half grade.

Note: all stats from Fangraphs and current up to 7/8

To review all my picks, I'm going to do a table of hitters and a table of pitchers and how they've done before and after being in 2 to Watch. Normally, I love to provide lots of supporting stats to dig deeper, but today I'm only interested in results and outcomes, not the reasons why, so I'm going to mostly stick to the traditional stats. I included whether I said to buy or sell the player and the grade I give myself for that pick.

Let's start with the hitters I've profiled so far.

Player Week on 2tW Pre/Post 2tW PA AVG OBP SLG HR R RBI SB What I Said Grade
Chris Coghlan 2 Pre 27 0.304 0.385 0.696 2 4 2 1 Buy, Deep Lg B
Post 260 0.239 0.338 0.381 6 28 17 6
Jose Iglesias 3 Pre 54 0.396 0.453 0.479 0 5 2 4 Sell C
Post 219 0.294 0.346 0.345 1 14 12 5
Adam Lind 4 Pre 88 0.333 0.398 0.577 4 8 13 0 Buy A
Post 237 0.287 0.367 0.512 12 29 40 0
Ryan Braun 5 Pre 100 0.226 0.280 0.387 5 11 13 1 Buy A
Post 243 0.29 0.364 0.523 10 39 42 11
Shin-soo Choo 6 Pre 119 0.214 0.311 0.417 4 10 14 0 Buy C
Post 216 0.247 0.319 0.407 8 29 23 0
Jimmy Paredes 7 Pre 109 0.346 0.376 0.625 6 18 22 1 Sell B
Post 160 0.272 0.300 0.404 5 19 20 2
Javier Baez 9 Pre Minors Buy Incomplete
Post Injured
Joe Panik 10 Pre 215 0.303 0.376 0.447 4 26 21 2 Buy A
Post 134 0.311 0.366 0.443 2 17 9 1
Matt Kemp 11 Pre 251 0.249 0.283 0.346 2 32 32 6 Sell A
Post 104 0.223 0.279 0.394 4 9 12 1
Logan Forsythe 13 Pre 284 0.293 0.373 0.454 8 28 32 7 Buy C
Post 54 0.217 0.333 0.261 0 5 2 0
Eugenio Suarez 13 Pre 40 0.278 0.333 0.417 1 2 6 1 Buy, deep leagues A
Post 48 0.37 0.396 0.522 2 3 8 2

Now, I'm going to say some stuff about each of these guys. I'll probably skip a few of them if there is nothing to note.

Chris Coghlan

I bumped up his grade from the quarter season review from a C to a B because he has been solid and consistent all year. For deep leagues, he has delivered decent power and speed.

Jose Iglesias

I changed his grade from an A to a C because I don't think I gave him enough credit for his excellent batting average and on-base percentage for a shortstop, despite his middling power production. His power has returned to previous career averages, but his other stats have stuck around, so he's actually a decent shortstop option.

Adam Lind

His grade got bumped from a C to an A because he has been simply excellent this year. He has exceeded my expectations and is not slowing down.

Ryan Braun

zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz... no changes needed. He's been very good since April.

Shin-Soo Choo

I downgraded him from an A to a C because his power has not really bounced back like I thought it might. He is doing much better than his terrible April, but is still just a 5th OF in standard leagues. Far from what he used to be.

Jimmy Paredes

I still don't know what to think of this guy. His power has returned to his old levels, expectedly, and his 0.356 BABIP won't last, but for a middle infielder, his stats don't look so bad. I'm still sellling, so his grade stays a B.

Javier Baez

:( Injured just before his likely callup back to Chicago. We all wait to see if his AAA improvements can translate to the Show.

Joe Panik

Panik has kept up almost the exact same pace as before he appeared in these electronic pages in every stat. He's remained an excellent second base option in any league.

Matt Kemp

I was (and am) worried about Kemp's power being sapped by an unannounced injury. His power is still way down, despite some recent homers. I still don't see a resurgence this season. And that's coming from someone that owns him and stupidly keeps starting him (my entire bench is on the DL, so it's somewhat justified).

Logan Forsythe

He has struggled in the handful of games since he appeared on 2 to Watch and that forced me to give myself a C on him, but that sample size is very small and I still expect him to be a top-10 second baseman the rest of the way.

Eugenio Suarez

Wow! What a fortnight for Suarez! While I love the power, it won't last like this. Nonetheless, he's still a great deep league shortstop option the rest of the season.

Now, we march on to the pitchers!

Player Week on 2tW Pre/Post 2tW IP ERA FIP xFIP WHIP K/9 What I Said Grade
Nate Karns 2 Pre 12.2 4.97 4.24 4.63 1.03 7.11 Buy, Deep Lg A
Post 85.1 2.95 3.49 3.59 1.28 8.86
Eddie Butler 3 Pre 16 2.25 4.95 5.26 1.63 5.63 Sell A
Post 38.1 5.87 5.84 5.08 1.9 4.46
Shawn Tolleson 4 Pre 9.1 1.93 0.67 1.56 0.86 12.54 Buy B
Post 26.1 2.73 3.57 3.62 1.14 8.54
Evan Scribner 5 Pre 15.1 1.17 2.87 2.35 0.72 10.57 Buy C
Post 26.2 5.06 4.77 2.92 1.16 8.78
Colby Lewis 6 Pre 45 2.4 3.29 4.33 1.02 6.8 Sell A
Post 59.1 6.67 4.43 4.68 1.47 6.22
Hector Santiago 7 Pre 48 2.25 4.09 4.58 1.23 8.25 Buy B
Post 53.1 2.53 4.17 4.41 0.98 7.93
Raisel Iglesias 9 Pre 19 4.26 2.71 4.39 1.42 8.05 Buy Incomplete
Post 5.2 7.94 3.61 2.54 1.59 12.71
Chad Bettis 10 Pre 33.1 2.7 2.36 3.61 1.11 7.29 Sell A
Post 30.1 7.42 6.24 4.1 1.71 7.42
Robbie Ray 11 Pre 17.2 1.53 3.36 4.04 1.13 6.62 Sell C
Post 32.1 2.51 2.58 4.2 0.96 6.96
Ivan Nova 12 Pre N/A Sell A
Post 17 2.65 4.79 5.14 1.41 4.76
Patrick Corbin 12 Pre N/A Buy Incomplete
Post 5 3.6 1.88 3.55 1.6 5.4

Nate Karns

Karns has been better than I expected so far and may be forcing his way into standard mixed league company. He has been great in deep leagues. He doesn't show any red flags for regression.

Eddie Butler

He was bad enough to be demoted, so there's not much for me to say.

Shawn Tolleson

Well, he did get the closer's job after appearing in 2 to Watch, but his stats have also declined. His numbers aren't bad for a reliever, but they aren't dominant either. I downgraded him from an A to a B due to his skill decline. He's still a good closer for the rest of the year, just not a top-10 option like I thought he might be.

Evan Scribner

Well, he's been giving up homers at an absurd 2.29 HR/9 rate, which has destroyed his ERA. His WHIP is still good and he still isn't walking anyone, so if he can stop giving up so many fence-clearers, he could get his ERA back under 3, I believe. His struggles have cost him a shot at the closer's role for now though. Even if Clippard is traded, Scribner is no longer next in line. I gave myself a C because of his steep decline in outcomes.

Colby Lewis

I upgraded him from a B to an A because at the quarter point, it looked like he might be better than I gave him credit for. Now, he looks just as bad as I originally thought and should not be rostered anywhere.

Hector Santiago

He has basically kept up his production and cut down on his WHIP. He is due for some regression, but I still think he is under appreciated, so no change to the grade there.

Raisel Iglesias

This is an incomplete grade since Iglesias only had one start after 2 to Watch's profile and he has been injured ever since. He's on a rehab assignment, so he should be back soon and we can evaluate him much better then.

Chad Bettis

He has been as bad as I imagined. It really bothers me when a player is playing over their head and regression refuses to knock them back to earth. Well, regression has been cruel to Bettis and he is definitely not a pitcher you want.

Robbie Ray

I was torn about Ray back when I originally wrote about him and I kind of still am. I don't like his skill set with low strikeouts, but his results so far have been surprising. His FIP and WHIP show a pitcher with good command and control. His xFIP says he has been very lucky so far. Reality is probably between his FIP and xFIP, but where? He's still someone I would sell, but I wouldn't fault you for taking a chance on him keeping up his current pace a little and ending up with a 3.5 ERA or so. I could only give myself a C here since he has maintained his outcomes.

Ivan Nova and Patrick Corbin

These two have returned from Tommy John since I wrote about them. Nova has had a great ERA with terrible supporting numbers and looks bad. He might be bad all year, so I am giving myself an A for suggest you sell him. Corbin gets an incomplete grade because he only has one mediocre start since coming back. There isn't enough information to determine if I was correct in buying him.

My total GPA: 3.33

"They've got a homegirl named Abby. Her last name Cadabby. I showed her my report card. She said: Not too Shabby"

Next week, I'm using the all-star break to review my pre-season predictions. It could get ugly. Until then, Tschus!