clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

Equivalent Fantasy Average: August pitcher wrap-up

Craig Kimbrel has taken over first place in the fantasy rankings among all pitchers, which makes way more sense than Francisco Rodriguez being there.

Jason Getz-USA TODAY Sports

Time for some personal therapy.

So y'all know I have a novel coming out in May. (If you didn't know that, here's the news. (If you're the guy that got upset with me in the comments for posting a picture of a girl in zombie makeup, don't click that link. (Also, you're kind of a jerk.)))

Anyway, it's always been a dream of mine to write a book, ever since I went to a book fair in, like, second grade, and realized that people of any age could write a book. I wrote my first one in the weeks that followed. It was ... not good. It did feature the main characters going to a baseball game in which Will Clark hit, like, three grand slams, so it made me happy, but yeah, not a good book.

The point is that something I wished for for a long time is coming true, so I should be just annoyingly happy about it. And I am happy, but I find myself keeping it in check. In an email thread with a fantasy-writing friend I hadn't spoken to in some months, I made sure to keep my excitement a bit muted, and he was like "Dude, you should be going crazy about this."

Frankly, I probably should. But I'm so used to the other shoe dropping that I often struggle with being excited enough about good things. When I got the acceptance, I was worried it was a fake email. When I got confirmation, I worried it was a mistake. When I got the contract, I worried they'd change their mind. Once I get the book, I'll worry no one will like it, or no one will buy it, or it'll be full of awful typos. I'm really good at worst-case-scenario-ing.

Which brings me to this month's pitcher update of Equivalent Fantasy Average. When I first came up with EFA in the offseason, I worried I was coming up with something stupid. When people responded well to it, I worried I hadn't gone in-depth enough. When the offensive side came together, I realized I needed the pitching side.

Well, now I have the pitching side, and I keep worrying that it's just really stupid and I'm not smart enough to realize that. I don't know. And I'm not saying this to ask you to reassure me in the comments, not really. I am only so good at math, at stats, and I know this could be improved. So, if you're adept and inclined, check over my methodology, and let me know if I'm smart, or if I'm dumb. Primarily if I'm dumb. I wanna learn.

And now the numbers through August:

Rank Player EFA
1 Craig Kimbrel 2.03
2 Francisco Rodriguez 2.05
3 Greg Holland 2.07
4 Clayton Kershaw 2.12
5 Kenley Jansen 2.13
6 Fernando Rodney 2.27
7 David Robertson 2.28
8 Trevor Rosenthal 2.30
9 Johnny Cueto 2.32

Huston Street 2.32
11 Koji Uehara 2.34
12 Jonathan Papelbon 2.35
13 Zach Britton 2.38
14 Glen Perkins 2.40
15 Felix Hernandez 2.44
16 Steve Cishek 2.45
17 Rafael Soriano 2.46
18 Aroldis Chapman 2.51
19 Madison Bumgarner 2.56
20 Corey Kluber 2.59
21 Max Scherzer 2.61
22 Addison Reed 2.62
23 Chris Sale 2.63
24 Mark Melancon 2.67
25 Cody Allen 2.68
26 Jon Lester 2.71
27 Sergio Romo 2.72
28 Garrett Richards 2.76

Adam Wainwright 2.76
30 Zack Greinke 2.77

Joe Nathan 2.77
32 Jake McGee 2.78

David Price 2.78
34 Sean Doolittle 2.81
35 Hector Rondon 2.84

Masahiro Tanaka 2.84
37 Joe Smith 2.87
38 Tyson Ross 2.88
39 Jenrry Mejia 2.90
40 Matt Shoemaker 2.91

Julio Teheran 2.91
42 Hisashi Iwakuma 2.93
43 Lance Lynn 2.95
44 Hyun-Jin Ryu 2.97

Stephen Strasburg 2.97
46 Yu Darvish 2.99
47 Wade Davis 3.01

LaTroy Hawkins 3.01
49 Scott Kazmir 3.04
50 Dellin Betances 3.05

Kimbrel finally takes over first, after Rodriguez had it the last two months. As it should be. ... Man, Kershaw is good. ... Guys like Rosenthal, Reed and Nathan being this high really speaks to the lack of impact a closer's runs allowed really has. There just isn't the denominator.

Rank Player EFA

Sonny Gray 3.05
52 Phil Hughes 3.07
53 Pat Neshek 3.08
54 Casey Janssen 3.09
55 Rick Porcello 3.11

Alex Wood 3.11
57 Joaquin Benoit 3.12

Ervin Santana 3.12

Jered Weaver 3.12
60 Joakim Soria 3.13

Tony Watson 3.13
62 Tanner Roark 3.14

Jordan Zimmermann 3.14
64 Doug Fister 3.18
65 Ian Kennedy 3.21
66 Alex Cobb 3.22

Cole Hamels 3.22
68 Jake Arrieta 3.23

Santiago Casilla 3.23
70 Mike Dunn 3.24
71 Wei-Yin Chen 3.25

Tyler Clippard 3.25

John Lackey 3.25

Wily Peralta 3.25

Alfredo Simon 3.25
76 James Shields 3.26
77 Jake Odorizzi 3.27
78 Danny Duffy 3.28
79 Collin McHugh 3.29
80 Chad Qualls 3.30

Chris Young 3.30
82 Andrew Miller 3.31
83 Dallas Keuchel 3.32
84 Zack Wheeler 3.34
85 Brad Boxberger 3.35

Darren O'Day 3.35
87 Jonathan Broxton 3.36

Bartolo Colon 3.36

Kyle Lohse 3.36

Yordano Ventura 3.36
91 Jean Machi 3.37

Drew Smyly 3.37
93 Henderson Alvarez 3.39

Jorge de la Rosa 3.39

Jeff Samardzija 3.39

Chris Tillman 3.39
97 Carlos Carrasco 3.40

Jason Hammel 3.40

Mike Leake 3.40
100 Jacob deGrom 3.41
Rank Player EFA
101 Bud Norris 3.42
102 Jesse Chavez 3.43

Tim Hudson 3.43

Anibal Sanchez 3.43

Edinson Volquez 3.43
106 Chris Archer 3.44

Jason Grilli 3.44

Dan Otero 3.44
109 John Axford 3.45

Homer Bailey 3.45

Josh Beckett 3.45
112 Jesse Hahn 3.46

Bryan Morris 3.46

Zach Putnam 3.46

Jason Vargas 3.46
116 Roenis Elias 3.47

Tommy Hunter 3.47
118 Bryan Shaw 3.48
119 A.J. Ramos 3.49
120 Jose Fernandez 3.50
121 R.A. Dickey 3.51

Fernando Salas 3.51
123
Jarred Cosart 3.52

Yovani Gallardo 3.52
125 Dan Haren 3.52

Marcus Stroman 3.52

Carlos Torres 3.52
128 Gerrit Cole 3.53

Tom Koehler 3.53

Michael Wacha 3.53
131 Chase Anderson 3.54

Yusmiero Petit 3.54

Jose Quintana 3.54

Ryan Vogelsong 3.54
135 Josh Collmenter 3.55

Mike Fiers 3.55

Aaron Loup 3.55

Neil Ramirez 3.55
139 Zach Duke 3.56

Drew Hutchison 3.56
141 Gio Gonzalez 3.57

Luke Gregerson 3.57
143 Jeurys Familia 3.58

Aaron Harang 3.58
145 Ken Giles 3.59

Tim Lincecum 3.59

Dale Thayer 3.59
148 Brad Brach 3.60

Matt Garza 3.60

Kyle Hendricks 3.60
Rank Player EFA

Hiroki Kuroda 3.60

Seth Maness 3.60

Yoervis Medina 3.60

Jake Petricka 3.60

Drew Pomeranz 3.60

Mark Buehrle 3.60
157 C.J. Wilson 3.61

Antonio Bastardo 3.61
159 Brett Cecil 3.62

Casey Fien 3.62

Kyle Gibson 3.62

J.A. Happ 3.62
163 Kelvin Herrera 3.63

Brandon McCarthy 3.63

Pedro Stop 3.63

Vance Worley 3.63
167 Al Alburquerque 3.64

Josh Fields 3.64

J.P. Howell 3.64

Mat Latos 3.64

Tom Wilhelmsen 3.64
172 Fernando Abad 3.65

Aaron Crow 3.65

James Paxton 3.65

Justin Verlander 3.65
176 Neftali Feliz 3.66

Shawn Kelley 3.66

Brad Ziegler 3.66
179 Grant Balfour 3.67

Ronald Belisario 3.67

Jake Diekman 3.67

Ernesto Frieri 3.67

Jon Niese 3.67
184 Kevin Gausman 3.68

Josh Tomlin 3.68

Tsuyoshi Wada 3.68
187 Shane Greene 3.69

Wade Miley 3.69

Hector Santiago 3.69
190 Miguel Gonzalez 3.70

Evan Marshall 3.70

Drew Storen 3.70
193 Danny Farquhar 3.71

Danny Salazar 3.71
195 Dillon Gee 3.72

Kevin Jepsen 3.72

Jeff Locke 3.72

Michael Pineda 3.72

Jordan Walden 3.72
200 Matt Lindstrom 3.73
Rank Player EFA

Kevin Quackenbush 3.73
202 Trevor Bauer 3.74

Roberto Hernandez 3.74

Aaron Sanchez 3.74

Junicho Tazawa 3.74

Carlos Villanueva 3.74
207 Craig Stammen 3.75
208 Bronson Arroyo 3.76

Jason Frasor 3.76

Francisco Liriano 3.76

Joel Peralta 3.76
212 Andrew Cashner 3.77

Jeremy Guthrie 3.77

Jordan Lyles 3.77

Adam Warren 3.77
216 Jeremy Affeldt 3.78

A.J. Burnett 3.78

Cliff Lee 3.78

Dustin McGowan 3.78
220 David Buchanan 3.79

Charlie Morton 3.79
222 Marco Estrada 3.80

David Phelps 3.80
224 Jaime Garcia 3.81

Shelby Miller 3.81
226 Tyler Skaggs 3.82

Jose Veras 3.82
228 Gavin Floyd 3.83

Daisuke Matsuzaka 3.83

Hector Noesi 3.83

Nick Vincent 3.83

Justin Wilson 3.83
233 Joba Chamberlain 3.84

Ryan Cook 3.84

Odrisamer Despaigne 3.84

Adam Ottavino 3.84
237 Scott Feldman 3.85

Charlie Furbush 3.85

Mike Minor 3.85

Will Smith 3.85
241 Edward Mujica 3.86

Eric O'Flaherty 3.86

Martin Perez 3.86

Shae Simmons 3.86

Tyler Thornburg 3.86
246 Neal Cotts 3.87

Matt Thornton 3.87
248 Steve Delabar 3.88

Nathan Eovaldi 3.88

David Hale 3.88
Rank Player EFA
251 Dylan Axelrod 3.89

Robbie Erlin 3.89

Tommy Milone 3.89

Anthony Ranaudo 3.89

Alex Torres 3.89

Travis Wood 3.89
257 Rubby de la Rosa 3.90

CC Sabathia 3.90
259 Jerry Blevins 3.91

Jeremy Hellickson 3.91

Jim Henderson 3.91
262 Jared Burton 3.92

Colby Lewis 3.92

Jose Valverde 3.92
265 Jimmy Nelson 3.93
266 Chris Capuano 3.94

Javier Lopez 3.94
268 Luis Avilan 3.95

Rex Brothers 3.95

Sergio Santos 3.95

Taijuan Walker 3.95
272 Brett Anderson 3.96

Jake Peavy 3.96
274 John Danks 3.97

Brandon Kintzler 3.97

Brian Wilson 3.97
277 Matt Cain 3.98

Tony Cingrani 3.98

Jerome Williams 3.98
280
Trevor Cahill 3.99

Randall Deglado 3.99

Kyle Farnsworth 3.99

J.J. Hoover 3.99

Jim Johnson 3.99

Sam LeCure 3.99

Alexi Ogando 3.99

Chase Whitley 3.99
288 David Carpenter 4.00

T.J. House 4.00

Carlos Martinez 4.00

Manny Parra 4.00

J.J. Putz 4.00

Kevin Siegrist 4.00
294 Joe Kelly 4.01

Tyler Matzak 4.01

Paco Rodriguez 4.01
297 Scott Baker 4.02

Matt Harrison 4.02

Matt Moore 4.02

Bobby Parnell 4.02
Rank Player EFA
301 Ubaldo Jimenez 4.03

Brett Oberholtzer 4.03

Dan Straily 4.03

Eric Stults 4.03
305 Craig Breslow 4.04

Marco Gonzales 4.04

Allen Webster 4.04
308 Brandon Morrow 4.05

Vidal Nuno 4.05
310 Heath Bell 4.07

Clay Buchholz 4.07

Jason Motte 4.07

Ivan Nova 4.07

Nick Tepesch 4.07
315 Eddie Butler 4.08

Zach McAllister 4.08

Juan Nicasio 4.08

Chris Perez 4.08
319 Feliz Doubront 4.09

Brandon Maurer 4.09
321 Rafael Montero 4.10
322 Brad Hand 4.11

Brandon Workman 4.11
324 Andrew Heaney 4.12

Kyle Kendrick 4.12

Justin Masterson 4.12
327 Brad Peacock 4.13
328 Erasmo Ramirez 4.16

Wandy Rodriguez 4.16
330 Franklin Morales 4.17
331 Jhoulys Chacin 4.18
332 Kevin Correia 4.19

Edwin Jackson 4.19

Jacob Turner 4.19
335 Bruce Chen 4.21

Robbie Ross 4.21

Tanner Scheppers 4.21
338 Ricky Nolasco 4.30
339 Nick Martinez 4.32