Getting some inspiration from an article over at Hardball Times, Ray and I have put together our rankings of players who are 25 years or younger. These rankings are best viewed for dynasty leagues, as we have prepared them on the assumption of performance both in 2012 and going forward. As with their article, these rankings are for a standard 5x5 roto mixed league and all players ranked were born after 1/12/1986. You can find our lists below, and my thoughts after the jump.
|
Rank |
Jason |
|
Ray |
|
1 |
Justin Upton |
|
Justin Upton |
|
2 |
Mike Stanton |
|
Mike Stanton |
|
3 |
Clayton Kershaw |
|
Bryce Harper |
|
4 |
Felix Hernandez |
|
Andrew McCutchen |
|
5 |
Stephen Strasburg |
|
Clayton Kershaw |
|
6 |
Brett Lawrie |
|
Felix Hernandez |
|
7 |
Andrew McCutchen |
|
Eric Hosmer |
|
8 |
Bryce Harper |
|
Brett Lawrie |
|
9 |
Mike Trout |
|
Stephen Strasburg |
|
10 |
Starlin Castro |
|
Carlos Santana |
|
11 |
Matt Moore |
|
Matt Moore |
|
12 |
Carlos Santana |
|
Desmond Jennings |
|
13 |
Eric Hosmer |
|
Jay Bruce |
|
14 |
Jay Bruce |
|
Mike Trout |
|
15 |
Desmond Jennings |
|
Jesus Montero |
|
16 |
Jesus Montero |
|
Jason Heyward |
|
17 |
Dustin Ackley |
|
Starlin Castro |
|
18 |
Jason Heyward |
|
Matt Wieters |
|
19 |
Yu Darvish |
|
Buster Posey |
|
20 |
Buster Posey |
|
Madison Bumgarner |
|
21 |
Pablo Sandoval |
|
Yu Darvish |
|
22 |
Logan Morrison |
|
Logan Morrison |
|
23 |
Craig Kimbrel |
|
Pablo Sandoval |
|
24 |
Elvis Andrus |
|
Mat Latos |
|
25 |
Freddie Freeman |
|
Dustin Ackley |
|
26 |
Ike Davis |
|
Dee Gordon |
- Not a huge surprise here that #1 and #2 are Justin Upton and Mike Stanton. Upton is still just 24 years old, so he'll likely be at the top of this list again next year. What's not to like about a potential 30-30 outfielder who keeps getting better? Add to that a potential 50 homer bat that could be there as soon as this season, and it's an easy top 2.
- Likely one of the biggest disagreements between myself and Ray on this list is Bryce Harper. I could very well be eating my words at this time next year, but I think Harper does not make the team out of Spring Training and may not be up until near the end of the season. He is probably very close to ready right now, but I have to imagine that the Nationals' minor league affiliates will have a coronary if he doesn't spend some more time in AA and AAA so they can cash in on his popularity. For me, the only thing keeping him from the #3 spot is the fact that I think you won't get much from him this season.
- Another big difference is on Angels' OF Mike Trout. I think that the new staff in Anaheim is going to find a way to rid themselves of at least one of their excess outfielders, and get Trout legitimate playing time as soon as this year.
- Starlin Castro also appears to be a bit of a lightning rod at the moment, and not just for his problems off the diamond. I think that of the group of young shortstops who fit the qualification (Castro, Elvis Andrus, Dee Gordon, Alcides Escobar), Castro has the highest ceiling for offensive production. I think we honestly could see Castro post a 15 HR, 30-35 SB, .300 season within the next 3.
- I ranked the only reliever on either list, as I think Kimbrel is going to be the closer in Atlanta for many years. If he stays healthy (which is of course a huge caveat), I think he'll be good for 40+ saves, and 100+ strikeouts every year.
Let us know your thoughts - Are one (or both) of us insane? Is there someone you think should have been in our top 25 that was ignored? Let us hear it both here in the comments or via Twitter. You can follow me at @jasonsbaseball, and Ray at @faketeams.