clock menu more-arrow no yes

Filed under:

Who Would You Rather Have: Troy Tulowitzki or Jimmy Rollins?

New, 2 comments

I'm taking a look at NL shortstops and find that there is the top 3-the Marlins Hanley Ramirez, the Rockies Troy Tulowitzki and the Phillies Jimmy Rollins, and then you have several guys who disappointed this season: Rafael Furcal, JJ Hardy, and Stephen Drew to name a few.

There is speed to be had at the SS position in 2010 with Rollins and the Padres Everth Cabrera leading the way. I want to see whether the Mets Jose Reyes steals some bases in spring training before I include him in the top SB guys in the league.

Here are a look at the stats for Jimmy Rollins and Troy Tulowitzki, who, by the way, I was very wrong on in 2009:

Player AB R H 2B HR RBI BB KO SB BA OBP SLG
Rollins, Jimmy SS PHI 642 96 158 40 20 75 41 68 30 0.246 0.291 0.414
Tulowitzki, Troy SS COL 516 94 150 24 30 86 69 110 18 0.291 0.371 0.543

Tulo has come back from a terrible 2008 season to post a 30-86-16-.291 season in 2009. Whoever drafted Tulo is a very happy owner this season. Tulo has the better HR, RBI, and AVG, but Rollins has the SB and runs by a slight margin.

Is Rollins' 2009 season typical of what we will see in 2010? Can Tulo duplicate his 30-90 season in 2010?