clock menu more-arrow no yes

Filed under:

Who Would You Prefer? Alfonso Soriano Or Matt Kemp

New, comments

Reviewing raygu's Top 25 NL-Only Players, I noticed OF Alfonso Soriano listed ahead of Matt Kemp. I am toying with the idea that Kemp is the better value.

To buttress the burgeoning valuation, I went to PECOTA to see what it offers for both four- or five-category outfielders:

PLAYER AGE HR RBI R SB AVG
Soriano 33 38 119 103 25 0.281
Kemp 24 20 80 89 27 0.293

Yeah, that didn't work. So I went to Ron Shandler's Fantasy Forecaster:

PLAYER AGE HR RBI R SB AVG
Soriano 33 34 82 92 24 .284
Kemp 24 21 87 95 30 .283