Here is a list of catchers based on the weighting of the past three seasons with the most recent contributing 60%, 2006 at 30% and 2005 at 10%. Each player then has his score in each of the five traditional fantasy baseball categories ranked relative to his position peers and averaged to arrive at a composite score - the lower the better.
I did not change where some players ended, but I could not leave catchers like Jarrod Saltalamacchia behind so many mediocrities. So I added an "up" or "down" to some of those whose ranking looks to change significantly in 2008.
Comments are welcome and encouraged.
| Rank | Player | +/- |
| 1 | Posada Jorge | |
| 2 | Martin Russell | up |
| 3 | Mauer Joe | |
| 4 | Martinez Victor | |
| 5 | McCann Brian | |
| 6 | Rodriguez Ivan | |
| 7 | Varitek Jason | |
| 8 | Lo Duca Paul | |
| 9 | Hernandez Ramon | |
| 10 | Johjima Kenji | |
| 11 | Molina Bengie | |
| 12 | Pierzynski A.J. | |
| 13 | Olivo Miguel | down |
| 14 | Paulino Ronny | |
| 15 | Barrett Michael | down |
| 16 | Estrada Johnny | |
| 17 | Kendall Jason | |
| 18 | Zaun Gregg | |
| 19 | Laird Gerald | |
| 20 | Torrealba Yorvit | |
| 21 | Bard Josh | up |
| 22 | Buck John | |
| 23 | Navarro Dioner | up |
| 24 | Schneider Brian | |
| 25 | Napoli Mike | |
| 26 | Molina Yadier | |
| 27 | Ruiz Carlos | up |
| 28 | Ausmus Brad | down down |
| 29 | Ross David | up |
| 30 | Valentin Javier | |
| 31 | Snyder Chris | |
| 32 | Miller Damian | |
| 33 | Castro Ramon | up |
| 34 | Redmond Mike | |
| 35 | Saltalamacchia Jarrod | up up up |
| 36 | LaRue Jason | |
| 37 | Molina Jose | |
| 38 | Suzuki Kurt | up up |
| 39 | Shoppach Kelly | up |
| 40 | Bowen Rob | |
| 41 | Montero Miguel | up |
| 42 | Bennett Gary | |
| 43 | Iannetta Chris | up |
| 44 | Treanor Matt | |
| 45 | Flores Jesus | |
| 46 | Rabelo Mike | up |
| 47 | Mathis Jeff | up |
| 48 | Phillips Jason | |
| 49 | Munson Eric | |