I'm in a 12-team H2H dynasty league (40 man rosters - 32 MLB/8 MiLB). No keeper limits or $.
I finished 2nd last year and I'm gearing up for the title run this year.
I have proposed an offer where I trade Zimmermann/A.Russell/Sano for Lee/Kemp
-Bogaerts/Russell @ SS
-A. Ramirez/Sano @ 3B
-Upton/BUpton/Myers/Beltran/Werth @ OF [we start 5 OFers]
-Stras/G.Cole/Fernandez/Sanchez(DET)/Zimm/Salazar/Liriano @ SP
The other team has countered by removing Kemp from the deal and inserting Holliday.
I am concerned about Kemp's injuries and his ability to return to his previous dominance but prefer him over Holliday
Is giving up 2 elite prospects + Zimmermann for two 35 year-olds (Lee/Holliday) a wise move or am I giving up too much future?
Or do I insist that Kemp be included? Is the offer I proposed fair or am I out of line?
Any help/advice is appreciated!!! Thanks!!