FanPost

Six man Keeper dilemma


I am in a 12 team 6X6 category H2H league that we keep 6 players year to year. Here are some of the rules:

You can only keep players 3 additional years after they are drafted. (4 years total)

You can not keep more than 2 players at any one position.

All first round players can not be kept. The keeper designation is based on the round range they were taken in K1: Round 2-5, K2: Round 6-9, K3: Round 10-13, K4: Round 7+, K5: Round 10+, K6 Round 13+

My dilemma is this: I have Matt Kemp as my K1(for 2 more years) , but I also have Mike Trout (K6) for 2 more years, and Bryce Harper (K5) for 3 more years. Since I can't keep 3 OF I have to dump one of them.

Do I keep Trout and Kemp and dump Harper back in, or keep Harper and Trout and dump Kemp back in? If I dump Kemp then I can keep David Wright or Hanley Ramirez as my K1. Here are the Keeper scenarios:

Team A K1: Kemp, K2: Aramis Ramirez/Allen Craig, K3: Kimbrel, K4: Wainwright, K5: B. Lawrie, K6: Trout

or

Team B K1: Hanley Ramirez/David Wright, K2: A-Ram or Allen Craig K3: Kimbrel, K4 Wainwright, K5: Harper, K6: Trout

I have won back to back championships, but I'm torn on whether to keep 2 of the best OF in Trout and Kemp for 2 more years, or dump Kemp in favor of the upside potential the next 3 years of Harper. Thoughts?