12 team 5×5 keeper league. We have a $29 cap for keepers that rises $3 each year, each players cost rises $1 each year and maxes out at $10. Each players cost is based on round drafted (1st rd = $10, 2nd rd = $9, down to 10th rd.. on which cost $1. All FA pickups in season are $2). Finished 2nd last year due to injuries. Positions: C, 1B, 2B, SS, 3B, CI, MI, 4OF, UTIL, 4SP, 2RP, 3P, 5 Bench. I also traded CSantana© – 5pts, BAnderson(SP) – 2pts, and Cano(2B) – 8pts in various deals to get some additional keeper points and high draft picks, so they are not in my list.

Out of this list who do I keep?

10 – Reyes(OF), Tulo (SS)
9 – Kemp(OF), AGon(1B), Sabathia(SP), Gallardo(SP)
8 – Ellsbury(OF)
7 – Lee(SP)
6 – Ethier(OF)
5 –
4 – Stanton(OF)
3 – Beltre(3B), Lawie(3B), Freeman(1B), Hosmer(1B), JJohnson(RP)
2 – Machado(3B), Crawford(OF), Goldsmidt(1B), Rutledge(SS/2B), Meyers(OF), Lester(SP), Rosario©, Bonifacio(OF/IF), Holland(RP), Cobb(SP)
1 – AHill(2B)

I’m thinking its time to rebuild and keep the cheap guys and thow back hte high-priced guys. My current idea is to keep: Stanton(4), Beltre(3), Lawrie(3), Freeman(3), Goldshmidt(2), Hill(1), Machado(2), Crawford(2), Rutledge(2), Lester(2), Myers(2), and Hosmer(3). This does give me a glut of CIs, but I have been unable to get good value for them in trades.