Two Start Pitchers: Week of May 7-13

DETROIT, MI - MAY 02: Justin Verlander #35 of the Detroit Tigers throws a sixth inning pitch while playing the Kansas City Royals at Comerica Park on May 2, 2012 in Detroit, Michigan. Kansas City won the game 3-2. (Photo by Gregory Shamus/Getty Images)

Note: This post is best viewed in "wide" mode - click the appropriate link in the gray box at the top right of the page.

A very light Thursday (only 6 games) means that only 36 pitchers will be making 2 starts this week, making all of the guys on this list a relatively hot commodity. A doubleheader between the White Sox and Indians on Monday threatened to throw each rotation in disarray, but both teams will be calling up spot starters, and their rotations will continue on uninterrupted.

This week, the online Google Spreadsheet (make sure you're viewing the correct week) contains some extra data that does not appear in this post for space reasons. We know that certain statistics start to stabilize fairly early on in the season, and many of the pitchers on this list have surpassed or are approaching 150 total batters faced (TBF), which is the point at which we can start to believe in K/PA (expressed as a percentage), GB%, and LD%. [Source] I have included all of these stats for each pitcher, as well as ERA, xFIP, and ERA-xFIP. Additionally, I have included the rank of each park as a run environment in 2011 and the rank of each offense faced (by OBP, as of 5/5).

Ratings (0 is the lowest possible score; 5 is the highest) are based on my own subjective opinion on a given pitcher's talent level and recent form, with considerations made for ballpark and opposing offense. I've included comments for all 36 pitchers. These are drive-by comments and many of them are based on small sample size, but I've tried to be as informative as possible. I'm happy to discuss any pitcher on a deeper level in the comments or on Twitter.

Follow the jump for this week's two start pitchers.

As always, probable starters are subject to change.

Pitcher This Week's Schedule Own% Rating Comment
Justin Verlander T (@SEA), Su (@OAK) 99 5 The reigning CY/MVP faces two very questionable teams.
Edwin Jackson T (@PIT), Su (@CIN) 33 4.5 All of his numbers are up, and they're all (mostly) sustainable. Criminally underowned
James Shields T (@NYY), Su (@BAL) 98 4 Doing so many things right. Only drawback is matchup @NYY
Roy Halladay M (NYM), Su (SD) 99 4 Showing signs of aging, but you can't just bench him if you've got him
Jered Weaver M (@MIN), Su (@TEX) 99 4 No reason to think he won't continue his no-hit stuff, but @TEX is a death trap
Wandy Rodriguez M (MIA), Su (@PIT) 72 4 Some pretty tasty matchups, and he's not a guy who hurts himself.
Tommy Hanson M (@CHC), Su (@STL) 94 4 Imagine what his numbers would look like with a normal BABIP (currently .330)
Ricky Romero T (@OAK), Su (@MIN) 93 3.5 Hard contact (20.3 LD%) not turning into hits (.214 BABIP). Matchups in his favor, though
Lance Lynn M (@ARI), Su (ATL) 86 3.5 I wish I'd jumped on this bandwagon sooner. Don't expect 1.60, but he's the real deal.
Doug Fister M (@SEA), Sa (@OAK) 65 3.5 Returns from the DL with 2 very favorable matchups
Edinson Volquez M (COL), Su (@PHI) 51 3.5 The walks are hard to swallow, but he's doing everything else right.
Jeff Samardzija M (ATL), Su (@MIL) 29 3.5 Hard contact (26.7 LD%) is worrying. Ks are encouraging (9.09 K/9, 13.0 SwStrk%)
Jonathon Niese M (@PHI), Su (@MIA) 45 3 Was last game against HOU the real Niese or a blip? Against these offenses, who cares?
Yovani Gallardo M (CIN), Su (CHC) 95 3 Gallardo clearly needs to get Greinke to leave him alone
Philip Humber M (@CLE), Su (KC) 25 3 Which Humber will show up this week? Crazy stat of the week: 70.8 FStrk%. Yeah.
Ted Lilly M (SF), Su (COL) 71 3 A .169 BABIP with 84.1% LOB won't continue, esp as SwStrs continue to decline
Daniel Bard T (@KC), Su (CLE) 36 2.5 F-Strike%: 63.4 - so why is he walking so many people?
Justin Masterson T (CWS), Su (@BOS) 53 2.5 Fastball velocity drops, walks skyrocket. Still a reliable groundball machine
Matt Harrison M (@BAL), Sa (LAA) 46 2.5 Dip in fastball velocity a source of problems; OTOH, GB% (53.8) is encouraging
Felix Doubront M (@KC), Sa (CLE) 6 2.5 LD% and BABIP (.352) are a concern, SwStr% (8.2) suggests K-rate will drop
Josh Tomlin M (CWS), Sa (@BOS) 3 2.5 Has feasted on CWS (x2), KC (x2), and SEA. BOS won't be so easy
Neftali Feliz T (@BAL), Su (LAA) 76 2 Ks have dropped as expected, but walks continue to be a problem.
Jarrod Parker T (TOR), Su (DET) 21 2 ERA (1.38) won't last - F-Strike%=48.1, LOB% = 86.7, 0 HR. When will regression come?
Ivan Nova T (TB), Su (SEA) 54 2 K-rate appears to be unsustainable, and TB at home is not a good matchup
Joe Saunders M (STL), Su (SF) 51 2 Increased use of 2-seamer has led to more GBs. Regression to ERA is coming.
Jake Arrieta T (TEX), Su (TB) 16 2 Can he keep up a 7.75 K/9 with a 6.3 SwStr%? Probably not the week to find out
Drew Pomeranz M (@SD), Su (@LAD) 6 2 LD%=33.9, BABIP=.310. Something's got to give.
Bronson Arroyo M (@MIL), Su (WAS) 8 2 Only really worth the risk if both matchups are great. They're not.
Carlos Zambrano M (@HOU), Su (NYM) 26 1.5 He's better than you think, but so are HOU and NYM.
A.J. Burnett T (WAS), Su (HOU) 18 1.5 ERA-xFIP=5.11. That will happen when 10 GBs of 18 BIP turn into 12 hits.
Barry Zito M (@LAD), Su (@ARI) 33 1.5 Almost every peripheral points to hard negative regression. Don't get sucked in.
Liam Hendriks T (LAA), Su (TOR) 0 1 A lot like Liriano, but with fewer walks…and fewer strikeouts
Blake Beavan M (DET), Su (@NYY) 2 1 Doesn't strike guys out (3.86 K/9) or induce GBs (33.9%). Where's the upside?
Francisco Liriano M (LAA), Sa (TOR) 21 1 ERA-xFIP is 4.52…but ERA is 9.97
Jonathan Sanchez M (BOS), Su (@CWS) 9 1 Continues to roll with a BB/9 above and a K/9 below 7.
Brian Matusz M (TEX), Sa (TB) 1 1 At least he'll be pitching at home?

Trending Discussions

Log In Sign Up

Log In Sign Up

Please choose a new SB Nation username and password

As part of the new SB Nation launch, prior users will need to choose a permanent username, along with a new password.

Your username will be used to login to SB Nation going forward.

I already have a Vox Media account!

Verify Vox Media account

Please login to your Vox Media account. This account will be linked to your previously existing Eater account.

Please choose a new SB Nation username and password

As part of the new SB Nation launch, prior MT authors will need to choose a new username and password.

Your username will be used to login to SB Nation going forward.

Forgot password?

We'll email you a reset link.

If you signed up using a 3rd party account like Facebook or Twitter, please login with it instead.

Forgot password?

Try another email?

Almost done,

By becoming a registered user, you are also agreeing to our Terms and confirming that you have read our Privacy Policy.

Join Fake Teams

You must be a member of Fake Teams to participate.

We have our own Community Guidelines at Fake Teams. You should read them.

Join Fake Teams

You must be a member of Fake Teams to participate.

We have our own Community Guidelines at Fake Teams. You should read them.




Choose an available username to complete sign up.

In order to provide our users with a better overall experience, we ask for more information from Facebook when using it to login so that we can learn more about our audience and provide you with the best possible experience. We do not store specific user data and the sharing of it is not required to login with Facebook.