I'm in a bit of a predicament right now as I'm configuring my rankings. I honestly just want some people's opinions right now. Who do you like better in a long-term keeper: Justin Upton or Albert Pujols?

If it helps, this is a H2H Points league where we get 5 keepers. Pujols is considered the better player for this year by about 100 points, but could Upton's future MVP potential make him the pick over Pujols at say, the 5th pick, if both are available?