Keeper league with no contracts (can keep indefinitely) ... debating between Carlos Santana (I can get him for $12 / he values at $15) or Lance Berkman (I can get him for $4 / he values at $17) ... taking Santana takes a big hit out of my budget, but gives me a top tier catcher who is only 25, while Berkman is cheap but he is older and shrouded by uncertainty. But I'm a die hard Astros fan, thus a Berkman fan. But this could be his last season, who knows. AGH! Help please! My other 2 keepers are going to be Giancarlo Stanton (I can get him for $16 / values at $19) and Ryan Madson (I can get him for $1 / values at $10). Standard 11 team roto 5x5.

The rest of my options (value price in parenthesis) -

Evan Longoria $34 ($28)

Paul Konerko $10 ($21)

Neil Walker $4 ($10)

Mike Adams $3 ($17)

J.J. Putz $5 ($10)

Huston Street $3 ($5)