I am in a 16 team dynasty league and I have been offered two separate deals:

1. I was offered Matt Cain (2 years) for Matt Holliday (1 year) and Cory Luebke (2 years).

2. I was offered Jaime Garcia (2 years) and Johan Santana (1 year) for Matt Holliday (1 year)

Would you doeither deal? I am torn on what to do. I could use some SP's but I lose the power stats too.

Please give me your thoughts!

thanks.