I play in a 12 team H2H league. Keepers are typically 10, but going into this season each team has 8.

My keepers are Posey, Heyward, Beltre, Moore, Wainwright, Shields, Lawrie, Parker.

A guy offered me Posey for: Wil Myers and a 2nd round pick (keep in mind 12 teams/8 keepers)

That in of itself is light, but it's not a bad framework. I'm thinking of either countering with Myers, 1st rounder AND 2nd rounder, OR Myers, 2nd rounder and Jameson Taillon.

My MiLB pitching depth is good: I have Cole, Taijuan Walker, Hultzen, Archer. Adding Taillon would make that pretty insane.

Also of note: I just gave up a late round pick to get Matt Wieters in anticipation of a Posey deal. The pick wasn't valuable, and I think Wieters is an okay replacement.

Am I valuing Myers too high? Is he the guy I should go after for Posey?