B.J. Upton vs. Cameron Maybin...which CF would you prefer going forward in a very deep dynasty league? Traditional lineup (10 hitters, at real positions - i.e. RF, CF, LF instead of OF OF OF), but very deep statistical league - K/BB ratio, net SB, along with traditional BA/OBP/SLG. My team is on the low-end of a 12-team league, but quite young and a bit unlucky this year, so I could be competitive as early as next year.
I just acquired Upton this past offseason, but wonder if he really ever will put in all together - not quite expecting 2007 again, but a hybrid between 07 & 08 (i.e. HIGHER BA) would be nice. I would be acquiring Maybin, and I realize that there is no guarantee that Maybin will be better than Upton, or even his equal to this point. My biggest concern is that Upton gets dealt before July 31 and ends up in a hitters' haven, is rejuvenated by the change in scenery, and clobbers the lving snot out of the ball, while Maybin singles and doubles his way to mediocrity.
Just curious in your opinions - who would you want to roam CF for this year, and likely the next two years? Thanks!