Would you trade Clay Buchholz for Alex Gordon if you were me?

I'm not sure if Gordon is much of an upgrade over McGehee.  But he may be better than my bench or utility guys.

12 team, daily league
HR, RBI, R, SB, AVG, OPS  W, K, SV, QS, ERA, WHIP

C - avila
1 - gaby sanchez
2 - phillips
3 - mcgahee
SS - castro
OF - braun
OF - C Young
OF - BJ Upton
UT - Hosmer
UT - Smoak
BN - Dunn
BN - Tabata
SP-Halladay
SP-Weaver
SP-Marcum
SP-Buccholz
SP-Lilly
RP-K-rod
RP-Axford
RP-Nunez
BN-Kennedy
BN-Zimmermann
BN-Wandy
BN-Baker
BN-Britton
DL-Hughes
DL-Baily

Thanks!