12 team, 6x6 league with OPS and Losses as the added two categories (i didnt set up the league, not my choices for extra categories)

I'm a generally offensive heavy team, with Tulo, Uggla, Teix, R Zimmerman, Stubbs, Bourn, Ethier, Pablo...

My pitching is also solid, but not as deep with Hanson, Marcum, Morrow, Britton, Norriz, Danks, A Sanchez, and Matusz

I've been dealing with injuries (pablo, zimmerman) and ineffectiveness (uggla, tulo) so im afraid that when they rebound i will be over stuffed with offense, but I have been offered Jose Bautista and Ian Kennedy for Tommy Hanson and Andre Ethier. Which side would you rather take?