I'm in a pretty non-typical H2H Dynasty League that just finished it's first year. We're keeping 15 players (of 28 spots) and will steadily increase that number over the next two years. We can also keep 3 minor league players that don't count against the 15-keeper total. 14 teams; Hitter stats: wOBA, HR, TB-HR, AVG, SB-CS; Pitcher stats: QS, SV+HD, FIP, WHIP, K. There's also a $300 budget, so lots of things are a little off.

Recently I traded J.P. Arencibia, David Ortiz, Jed Lowrie, and Bryce Harper to a team that was clearly set on rebuilding. In exchange, I got Ichiro and Mike Stanton.

Was this a fair deal? Below are the rosters of the two deals before the deal happened.

Mine:

Player  Salary

Ramirez, Hanley SS FLA         45

Votto, Joey 1B CIN                 33

Youkilis, Kevin 1B BOS          22

Markakis, Nick RF BAL          23

Tulowitzki, Troy SS COL        39

Hill, Aaron 2B TOR                25

Posada, Jorge C NYY             11

Barton, Daric 1B OAK            2

Snider, Travis LF TOR            11

LaPorta, Matt 1B CLE            9

Morse, Mike OF WAS             1

Alvarez, Pedro 3B PIT            9

Ortiz, David DH BOS              1

Arencibia, J.P. C TOR              1

Santana, Carlos C CLE            13

Harper, Bryce RF WAS           11

Lowrie, Jed 2B BOS                1

Lewis, Colby SP TEX             2

Anderson, Brett SP OAK         21

Wood, Travis SP CIN              3

Gregerson, Luke RP SD           1

Pavano, Carl SP MIN               2

Hanrahan, Joel RP PIT            1

Gonzalez, Gio SP OAK           1

LeBlanc, Wade SP SD            1

Holland, Derek SP TEX          1

Bailey, Homer SP CIN            5

Owens, Rudy SP PIT               0

Teheran, Julio SP ATL            0

Pineda, Michael P SEA            0

His:

Player  Salary

Braun, Ryan LF MIL               49

Abreu, Bobby RF ANA           17

Pedroia, Dustin 2B BOS          30

Figgins, Chone 2B SEA           16

Rollins, Jimmy SS PHI            26

McCann, Brian C ATL            36

DeJesus, David LF OAK         3

Drew, J.D. RF BOS                 2

Morgan, Nyjer CF WAS          9

Kouzmanoff, Kevin 3B OAK   1

Callaspo, Alberto 3B ANA       8

Branyan, Russell 1B SEA        3

Gonzalez, Alex SS ATL           1

Kendall, Jason C KC               1

Suzuki, Ichiro RF SEA            22

Stanton, Michael RF FLA       9

Rivera, Mariano RP NYY       16

Lester, Jon SP BOS                 26

Fuentes, Brian RP MIN            7

Franklin, Ryan RP STL           6

Buehrle, Mark SP CHW           1

Myers, Brett SP HOU               1

Cueto, Johnny SP CIN            1

Duensing, Brian RP MIN         1

Happ, J.A. SP HOU                 1

Fister, Doug SP SEA               2

Porcello, Rick SP DET            1

Harang, Aaron SP SD              1

Olsen, Scott SP PIT                 1

Arrieta, Jake SP BAL               1

Crow, Aaron SP KC               0

Wheeler, Zack SP SF               0