Overrated Fantasy Running Backs
With most fantasy football drafts completed, there's a lot of data out there on where players have been drafted. If you have your draft this weekend, that kind of information can be invaluable. Here are a few RBs that I think are going way too early.
All average draft position data is from CBS Sportsline leagues
DeAngelo Williams, CAR (ADP: 9.73) -- Last year Williams averaged 5.55 yards per carry. As a comparison, Barry Sanders reached that level twice, in 1994 and again in 1997. Walter Payton came close (5.46) once. Emmitt Smith never did it. So if Emmitt couldn't do it, and Walter could barely do it once, and Barry could only do it twice in four years, you think DeAngelo Williams is going to run like that two years in a row?! I don't.
Chris Johnson, TEN (ADP: 13.57) -- Chris Johnson had a breakout season last year, but let's remember that he only has 251career carries. He's far from proven. The Titans were a heavily one-dimensional team last year and in order to pump up the passing game they brought in...Nate Washington. Ooh! Everybody in the league knows the way to defense the Titans is to stack the line and make the passing game beat you. Johnson should have a good season, but 13th overall? No way. He may not finish as the 13th best RB.
Pierre Thomas, NO (ADP: 34.94) -- He's hurt. He's sharing time with a now-healthy Reggie Bush. And RB Mike Bell looks very good so far. What's the attraction? Sure, he looked good last year, but he only has 181 career carries. He makes Johnson look like a veteran and people are picking him up in the 3rd round? I don't get it. He's unproven, he's sharing time and he's on a pass-first offense. This guy isn't even close to a third round value.
0 recs |
3 comments
Comments
.333
Can’t get behind the CJ and PT as overrated at those ADPs. Both players offer 40+ reception potential.
by faketeams on Sep 2, 2009 8:22 AM EDT reply actions 0 recs
True
But that’s a high draft pick for guys who haven’t proven all that much. Especially Thomas.
by Skeller on Sep 2, 2009 9:02 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
Thomas
In essentially half a season, he had more than 600 yards and 31 receptions plus 12 Tds. The question is a healthy Reggie Bush. While Thomas’ production showed no discernable drops in either rushing attempts or receptions when Bush played, there is still some question about how healthy Bush was when he returned.
At 35, Thomas is a bargain. A couple weeks ago, the paid experts (little discernable difference from the unpaid ones) were taking him in the late 2nd. Assuming the MCL injury is minor, he is a real bargain if he falls further in any format.
by faketeams on Sep 3, 2009 8:43 AM EDT reply actions 0 recs

by 












