FakeTeams: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:



Sports blogs for fans, by fans.
Around SBN: Steve McNair Dead - Former NFL QB Shot and Killed


spread the word

AL-Only Top 10 Cs

So with my NY Giants going down in flames yesterday thanks to some horrific play calling by Kevin Gilbride, I have decided that now is as a good a time as any to premier my list of Top 10 American League only catchers.

 

1. Joe Mauer - The best of the best. Earning most of his value from his average and RBI, and with the same cast around him, the Twins have a cornerstone that should've been signed to an extension years ago.

     PROJECTION: .320 AVERAGE // 11 HR //  102 RBI // 10 SB

2. Victor Martinez - A close second to Mauer. Came back from an injury to hit .300 in the last month of the season. Will give a lot of starts to Kelly Shoppach, but still qualifies as C and 1b. Still only 29, he may be ready for a power peak this year.

     PROJECTION: .301 AVG // 21 HR // 105 RBI // 0 SB

3. Mike Napoli - 2nd half tear was validated by a post season that saw him pitched to as the most dangerous Angels hitter. Entering into his age 27 season, he too could see a power spike.

     PROJECTION: .282 AVG// 29 HR // 80 RBI // 0 SB

4. Jorge Posada - Coming off a major down year, he could still drive in 90 hitting 8th in the Yankees lineup. Sleeper coming off last year.

     PROJECTION: .275 AVG // 17 HR // 77 RBI // 2 SB

5. Matt Wieters - The most heralded prospect of the year has unbelievable hype surrounding him, and some owner will grab him before some of the more proven commodities. If he simply walks on water, I would expect most people will be disappointed.

     PROJECTION: .277 // 16 HR // 68 RBI // 4 SB

6. AJ Pierzynski - Solid, steady White Sox backstop just keeps going, like the Eveready bunny, albeit with a little bit more attitude. Not much upside at this point, but plays in a great hitters park and has appeared in over 134 games every year over the last 3. Expect more of the same in 2009.

     PROJECTION: .265 AVG //  15 HR // 65 RBI // 2 SB

7. Kelly Shoppach - Career year when VMart went down last year. Forced the Indians hands, and will probably see 300 ABs this year as well. Big question marks with Ryan Garko and Travis Hafner leave the possibility of Shoppach playing 100 games at C and VMart playing the rest while also playing 1b.

     PROJECTION: .272 AVG //  15 HR // 55 RBI // 1 SB

8. Dioner Navarro - Power was a bit lacking last year, but he was only 23 years old for most of the season. I would expect an uptick in power, but not elite numbers.

     PROJECTION: .297 // 9 HR // 60 RBI // 2 SB

9. Taylor Teagarden - Impressive showing last year when eh was called up, but don't expect .310 average again. Also, plays in a great park for hitters, if he isn't moved before ST.

     PROJECTION: .268 AVG // 12 HR // 50 RBI // 3 SB

10. Rod Barajas - The catcher in TOR now that Gregg Zaun has gone, he will give you that one category, HR, and be liabilities in the others. Solid 2nd catcher if your league has 2 catching spots.

     PROJECTION: .244 AVG // 11 HR // 48 RBI // 1 SB

 

Well, that is my top 10 catchers in the American League. This list also shows why you shouldn't be spending huge amounts of your capital (either $$ or draft picks) with this group.

 

Additionally, some of my favorite sleepers for 2009 include guys like:

JP Arencibia, Max Ramirez, Jarrod Saltalamacchia (although it is hard to call him a sleeper anymore) and Dusty Ryan in DET.

 

 

 

1 recs | Comment 8 comments | Share on Facebook Digg!

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

Wieters

If the Orioles skip him over AAA I see a big struggle ahead. Pujols is the only player in recent memory to have a decent year while skipping that level. I can’t help but think at how highly Alex Gordon was hyped going into 2007 and how miserable he was all year at the plate after skipping AAA.

Ballsy call on Mike Napoli but I like it a lot.

I would try to find room for Jeff Clement in my top ten as I think all of this extra time in AAA will benefit him in 2009 and worry about Teagarden because of his contact problems.

by Jason Collette on Jan 12, 2009 3:58 PM EST reply reply actions actions   0 recs

Mauer skipped AAA

he did have 19 ABs his rookie year, but if I recall correctly that was on a rehab stint, as he made the team out of spring following AJ’s trade.

Obviously Mauer is special, but Weiters could be him with power.

by carverslacker on Jan 19, 2009 10:02 PM EST to parent up reply reply actions actions   0 recs

Travis Buck had a good year after skipping AAA

it was the next year when the injuries piled up that he sucked.

Dogfood Gangstas
Canned or Dry,
We Neva Die.

by Zonis on Feb 3, 2009 3:58 AM EST to parent up reply reply actions actions   0 recs

Toronto

I think that Barajas projection is what Arenciba will provide when he is recalled – low AVG double-digit HRs. Nice call on J.P. as a sleeper, too.

by faketeams on Jan 12, 2009 4:17 PM EST reply reply actions actions   0 recs

wtf

didnt napoli have 7sb’s and mauer 1 last year? no you predict mauer for 10 and napoli zero? wheres the love of your life Olivo?

by superherodj on Jan 12, 2009 10:09 PM EST reply reply actions actions   0 recs

Napoli

I admit that I did not get to see Napoli much the last month of the season (thanks direct tv for screwing me!). But I remember earlier in the year watching him a few times- it was just like 2007. He had the big uppercut swing that caused tons of k’s. Sure he would connect and bomb one every so often. But still, that .204 first half average for ‘07 caused lots of concern. He rebounded like a man possessed in Aug-Sept but there are still signs that he could regress very quickly. Aug-Sept at bats: 85, K’s: 24

I could see Napoli with a BA of .245-.255 and an OBP around .375. That and about 24-28 homers will get you a lot more than what most AL catchers provide. But he’ll be talked up and possibly overpriced come March. I could be wrong, of course. But if I see that uppercut swing in ST I’ll be the one talking him up, passing him over and hoping someone else drafts him way too early.

by acr on Jan 15, 2009 9:28 PM EST reply reply actions actions   0 recs

“But still, that .204 first half average for ‘07 caused lots of concern.” Should be “But still, that .204 first half average for ‘08 caused lots of concern.” Well actually it should be .204/.308/.472 for the first half of last season.

by acr on Jan 15, 2009 9:36 PM EST to parent up reply reply actions actions   0 recs

Napoli

His production in those few ABs will be hard for most people to avoid prorating over 400+ ABs. Unless he skips into the 12th round or sooner, I don’t really see a ton of risk involved with him.

by faketeams on Jan 16, 2009 9:40 AM EST to parent up reply reply actions actions   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to the SB Nation blog about Fantasy Sports.
Start posting on FakeTeams »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

P1_revis_profile_page_small
Trade Advice
Uconn_logo_small
OT: Arthurian Legend For 21st Century
Erin-andrews-butt-shot2_small
Jered Weaver... sell?
Fantasy_judgment_logo_small
Fantasy Sports Arbitration
Small
Brewers Trade Options
Small
What to do with Colby Rasmus?
Iwant2believe1240x1024_small
Corey Hart and Starting Pitching
Chicken_slam_large_2_small
Is Keith Law "borrowing" my material on Strasburg...
Mccovey_willie_3_small
NL-Only: E Dukes, G Parra, J Schafer
Mccovey_willie_3_small
NL-only: Bastardo, Medlen or West?

Post_icon New FanPost All FanPosts Carrot-mini


Managers

Uconn_logo_small faketeams

Beer_emotions_small Skeller

Small raygu

Authors

Unknown-4_small RJK

Official Partner of Yahoo! Sports