Dan (DC): Has Josh Hamilton made himself a top ten pick next season? Eric Karabell: (11:02 AM ET ) I don't think that's assured, and even if Hamilton keeps up with his RBI per game pace, I don't think I would go top 10. For one, he's an outfielder. The only OF I had top 10 for this year was Matt Holliday. I think Hamilton is a mid-second rounder, kind of how I felt about Prince Fielder for this season. Is Josh Hamilton A 1st Round Pick?