FakeTeams: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:



Around SBN: DTN Interviews SI's Austin Murphy Bar-right-arrows



MLB Trade Rumors: Will The Seattle Mariners Trade Erik Bedard?

The Seattle Mariners' entered the 2008 with the sheen of a play-off contender.  After acquiring an ace in Erik Bedard to head the rotation, many national pundits expected Bedard to lead the M's into the play-off especially considering their 88-win 2007.  (ed:  Funny.  The New York Mets did the same and also have struggled.  Is pitching really everything?)

71 games into the 2008 season and the Mariners look like a good bet to have the chance to draft San Diego State's Stephen Strasburg #1 overall next June.  The Mariners are the only team in the major leagues with a winning percentage under .400 - 3.5 games worse than the next closest team, the Washington Nationals.  There do not appear to be any measures that indicate the M's can get much better - 30th in OBP (.307) and 29th in SLG (.374).

So with the July 31st trading frenzy in its nascent stage, the firing of the man repsonsible for constructing this roster makes perfect sense.  Why let Bill Bavasi try to correct the msitakes in roster construction when he caused?

This morning's news that rookie catcher Jeff Clement will do the majority of the catching has greater implications than just acquiring catcher-eligibility for 2009 drafts (four appearances at C versus 11 at DH).  It means management is willing to correct mistakes of the previous regime.  This one being the three-year contract extension gave to catcher Kenji Johjima before the season started.

And if ownership is on board with that decision, is there any reason to believe that the Erik Bedard acquisition stays off-limits?  I don't think there is.  While some cannot fathom the Mariners acquiring two major league pieces the caliber of CF Adam Jones and lefty closer George Sherrill along with three pitching prospects, one of which, RHP Chris Tillman, looks to be a Top 50 one, I won't be surpised to see Bedard fetch something very close to that.

With half of 2008 and all of 2009 still to be played on Bedard's current contract, his value has to be seen through the lens of what the Texas Rangers received from the Altanta Braves for 1B Mark Teixeira last season.  If the M's can turn Bedard into an elite prospect and three mid-tier ones, I think the team should pull the trigger.

With Willie Bloomquist and Jeremy Reed sharing time in CF, the Mariners' could use a CF prospect.  Yeah the irony is thick given they dealt one for Bedard.  Starting pitching and bullpen help is required along with a bat at 1B and a quality 2B to push Jose Lopez.

Which system the pieces to make the Mariners move?  The New York Yankees could offer four or five mid-tier prospects but don't have that elite player to headline the offer.  The Boston Red Sox have the prospects, but does Jed Lowrie as a 2B entice enough?  Do the Red Sox even need Bedard?

How about the Chicago Cubs?  A package headed by Sean Gallagher and Rich Hill with CF Felix Pie and 2B Eric Patterson looks intriguing.  My sense is getting away from Lou Piniella and the win-now-play-veterans mentality in Chicago could do wonders for three of those four players. 

What I find interesting is Erik Bedard's market value remains in the same relative place it was this past winter when Johan Santana was the more accomplished pitcher, but his market value was considered less because he had just a a year remaining.  Now, C.C. Sabathia plays the Santana role.

Am I way off base?

Poll
Will the Seattle Mariners trade Erik Bedard?
No. Human nature says there was too much invested in acquiring him, and the organization will not overcome that.
35 votes
Yes. Bedard's trade value remains the same, and the offers will be too good to ignore.
67 votes

102 votes | Poll has closed

0 recs | Comment 4 comments

Read Related

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

could Joe

Torre remember how Bedard pitched last year vs the Yankees and suggest to Ned Colletti to deal for a starting pitcher with the Dodgers only 4.0 games behind the Dbacks who have come back to earth with a thud of late and had every opportunity to put away the Dodgers. With LA goling through a streak where they mustered 1 run or less in 12 of 20 games, they are STILL only 4 games behind the Dbacks….even with Webb winning 11 games….with Penny and possibly Kuroda headed to the DL, with Jones and Nomar on the DL.
Bedard, Billz, Lowe and Kershaw are a formidable 1-4 rotation for the next 3.5 months of the season. A package of Laroche, who Torre won’t play for some reason, Hu, McDonald, Meloan and Ethier could get a deal done for Bedard. Torre has fallen in love with Dewitt, but a package of Bedard and Beltre would be very enticing. Dewitt could spell Kent a few days a week.
Beltre was my favorite Dodger until Boras sent him to Seattle for the big money….there may not have been a more pissed off Dodger fan the day that news broke….livid doesn’t come close to how I felt. He’s gold glove 3bman with some pop, and he’s still young.
This deal could put LA atop the NL West, should Andruw Jones come back from the DL with a healthy knee and posible his power bat again.
A healthy Furcal would have to be a precursor to a deal like this.

raygu

by raygu on Jun 18, 2008 10:32 PM EDT   0 recs

LAD

Just like the past off-season, the Dodgers have the best combination of ready-to-play prospects necessary to be the King Maker the trading season. I am not convinced they have the werewithall to do so, though.

While I’d deal DeWitt, LaRoche is apparently out of favor due to some attitude issues. But if Milton Bradley can consistently find work, then the attitude issue is overcomeable. And a bit of unprofessional excuse-making on the part of the Dodgers.

by faketeams on Jun 19, 2008 9:36 AM EDT   0 recs

The Only Problem

With trading Bedard now is that even the notoriously laid-back Seattle media isn’t too keen on Bedard. Probably because he thinks it’s OK to be ‘just’ a 100 pitch pitcher. As a M’s fan I was excited to get him (even at the high cost) but I cannot wait for him to go now, especially since the team is very bad with not much hope of being better in the next year. If the M’s could get LaRoche, Ethier, and a couple “B” prospects, I think the trade would get done.

by MattoB on Jun 19, 2008 11:43 AM EDT   0 recs

Excellent point

I wanted to work in the fact Bedard pulled himslef at 99 pitches. It is one thing for the coaching staff to track pitches, but when the player does it, it smacks of selfishness. What is he doing, trying to preserve his arm for a long-term contract?

by faketeams on Jun 19, 2008 2:44 PM EDT to parent up   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to the SB Nation blog about Fantasy Sports.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recommended FanPosts

Small
MLB Free Agent Landing Predictions? Beat the Monkey!

Recent FanPosts

G_small
I need a Running Back This Week - Who Should I Pick Up
Uconn_logo_small
AL-Only & NL-Only Owners Wanted
Uconn_logo_small
OT: Presidential Election
Uconn_logo_small
2008 Awards ballots
Uconn_logo_small
Question and Answer
Small
for all the Manny being Manny haters....I bring you Joe Sheehan
Small
BA's Jim Callis on World Series possibilities
Small
Jonathon Broxton
Small
Trade Help

Post_icon New FanPost All FanPosts Carrot-mini


Managers

Uconn_logo_small faketeams

ad

Site Meter