What Do You Expect From Chase Headley?

Does it matter?

Should I drop David Murphy for Chase Headley?
Wes Padgett

Dave: I know it’s difficult to pass on the hype of a young rookie call-up, but I would stick with Murphy for now. The just-promoted Headley is an attractive option and will certainly succeed as the Padres’ new everyday left fielder, but the chances of him outperforming David Murphy from here on out is pretty slim.

Don’t get me wrong. Headley was hitting very well at Triple-A Portland (.305 average, 14 homers, 40 RBIs, 49 runs, .939 OPS), and you have to figure he is going to get plenty of playing time over such below-average outfielders as Jody Gerut and Justin Huber. But the Rangers’ Murphy is a much more attractive option now through the remainder of the season. He has been as equally productive on the road this season as he has been at his favorable home park, and he has been stealing bases, too—although not nearly as much as we would like. Simply put, Murphy appears to be a safer bet going forward, and I’d hang on to him.

There is also a Jay bruce question. Click through to see that answer. I like that answer a lot more.

To me, it is an easy decision – drop either player without second thought.

Winston Salem, NC: Chase Headly is getting the call-up soon. Should I grab him and drop either Russell Branyon or Edgar V. Gonzalez, both who have been playing well of late?
Steve Gardner: If you’re in a keeper league, there’s no question. Headley has been hitting very well at Triple-A. For the balance of this season, it’s a little closer call just because we don’t know how steep Headley’s learning curve will be. However, I think you have to take that chance because we have a pretty good idea what to expect from Branyan and Gonzalez doesn’t have much power upside.