Here are the values I would pay in 4X4 NL-only keeper leagues that follow traditional Rotisserie baseball rules. I know most people play 5x5 leagues, but the translation should be fairly simple. Ask yourself, whether a player is valued correctly relative to those above and below him i.e is Andruw Jones better than Chipper Jones. If you have a mixed league auction, ask yourself who will go for more money i.e. Adam laRoche or Edgar Renteria. And so on.

Have I left someone off? Certainly. Are this lists impervious to alteration? Certainly not. There is a ton of off-season left, and situations change. But to prepare properly, you must have a general lay of the land, and these rankings will provide that. Let the debate begin!